Safe Withdrawal Rate, the 4% Rule, Inflation, Social Security and the IRMAA Follow-Through
Enter a starting portfolio, a first-year withdrawal, a return and an inflation rate to see the year the money runs out or the balance left after 30 years. Then see what the research says about a safe withdrawal rate and what a pre-tax withdrawal does to Medicare premiums.

Withdrawal-rate history read from Bengen (Journal of Financial Planning, October 1994), Cooley, Hubbard and Walz (AAII Journal, February 1998, and Financial Counseling and Planning, 1999), Bengen's 2025 book and Morningstar's December 2025 report. RMD ages from 26 U.S.C. §401(a)(9). Social Security taxation from IRS Publication 915. IRMAA figures from the CMS 2026 fact sheet and 42 U.S.C. §1395r.
A $1,000,000 portfolio paying out $40,000 in year one, raised 3% a year for inflation and earning a steady 5%, covers all 30 years and ends with about $343,115. Start at $50,000 instead and the same portfolio runs out in year 25. Start at $30,000 and it ends with $1,337,822.
That spread is the whole retirement withdrawal strategy question. One percentage point of initial withdrawal rate separates money left over from money gone, on identical returns and identical inflation. The chart shows the three paths on the same axes.
The retirement withdrawal calculator below runs that math for any portfolio, withdrawal, return, inflation rate and horizon, with an optional Social Security benefit that starts in a year you choose. The rest of the page covers where the 4% rule came from, what the research says now, why the withdrawal has to grow, what a deterministic calculator cannot show, and the part most calculators skip: a withdrawal from a pre-tax account raises MAGI, and MAGI sets Medicare’s income-related surcharge two years later.
This retirement drawdown calculator is deterministic: one return every year, no randomness. It answers “how long will my money last” for a given set of assumptions, and it shows the inflation-adjusted withdrawal in years 10, 20 and 30 so the dollar amounts a client will actually spend are visible, not just the starting percentage.
Enter a starting portfolio, a first-year withdrawal, a return and an inflation rate. Results update as you type.
4.00% of the starting portfolio
Balance at the end of year 30
$343,115
The portfolio covers every withdrawal for 30 years at a 5.0% return and 3.0% inflation.
Withdrawal in year 10
$52,191
$40,000 x 1.030^9, before Social Security
Withdrawal in year 20
$70,140
$40,000 x 1.030^19, before Social Security
Withdrawal in year 30
$94,263
$40,000 x 1.030^29, before Social Security
Initial withdrawal rate
4.00%
$40,000 of $1,000,000 in year 1
| Year | Start balance | Withdrawal | From portfolio | Growth | End balance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $1,000,000 | $40,000 | $40,000 | $48,000 | $1,008,000 |
| 2 | $1,008,000 | $41,200 | $41,200 | $48,340 | $1,015,140 |
| 3 | $1,015,140 | $42,436 | $42,436 | $48,635 | $1,021,339 |
| 4 | $1,021,339 | $43,709 | $43,709 | $48,882 | $1,026,512 |
| 5 | $1,026,512 | $45,020 | $45,020 | $49,075 | $1,030,566 |
| 6 | $1,030,566 | $46,371 | $46,371 | $49,210 | $1,033,405 |
| 7 | $1,033,405 | $47,762 | $47,762 | $49,282 | $1,034,925 |
| 8 | $1,034,925 | $49,195 | $49,195 | $49,286 | $1,035,016 |
| 9 | $1,035,016 | $50,671 | $50,671 | $49,217 | $1,033,563 |
| 10 | $1,033,563 | $52,191 | $52,191 | $49,069 | $1,030,440 |
| 11 | $1,030,440 | $53,757 | $53,757 | $48,834 | $1,025,518 |
| 12 | $1,025,518 | $55,369 | $55,369 | $48,507 | $1,018,656 |
| 13 | $1,018,656 | $57,030 | $57,030 | $48,081 | $1,009,707 |
| 14 | $1,009,707 | $58,741 | $58,741 | $47,548 | $998,514 |
| 15 | $998,514 | $60,504 | $60,504 | $46,901 | $984,911 |
| 16 | $984,911 | $62,319 | $62,319 | $46,130 | $968,721 |
| 17 | $968,721 | $64,188 | $64,188 | $45,227 | $949,760 |
| 18 | $949,760 | $66,114 | $66,114 | $44,182 | $927,828 |
| 19 | $927,828 | $68,097 | $68,097 | $42,987 | $902,717 |
| 20 | $902,717 | $70,140 | $70,140 | $41,629 | $874,206 |
| 21 | $874,206 | $72,244 | $72,244 | $40,098 | $842,060 |
| 22 | $842,060 | $74,412 | $74,412 | $38,382 | $806,030 |
| 23 | $806,030 | $76,644 | $76,644 | $36,469 | $765,856 |
| 24 | $765,856 | $78,943 | $78,943 | $34,346 | $721,258 |
| 25 | $721,258 | $81,312 | $81,312 | $31,997 | $671,943 |
| 26 | $671,943 | $83,751 | $83,751 | $29,410 | $617,602 |
| 27 | $617,602 | $86,264 | $86,264 | $26,567 | $557,905 |
| 28 | $557,905 | $88,852 | $88,852 | $23,453 | $492,506 |
| 29 | $492,506 | $91,517 | $91,517 | $20,049 | $421,038 |
| 30 | $421,038 | $94,263 | $94,263 | $16,339 | $343,115 |
$1,000,000 to start, $40,000 withdrawn at the beginning of year 1, the withdrawal raised 3% each year, and the remaining balance earning 5% for the year. Nothing else moves.
| Year | Start balance | Withdrawal | After withdrawal | Growth at 5% | End balance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $1,000,000 | $40,000 | $960,000 | $48,000 | $1,008,000 |
| 2 | $1,008,000 | $40,000 x 1.03 = $41,200 | $966,800 | $48,340 | $1,015,140 |
| 3 | $1,015,140 | $41,200 x 1.03 = $42,436 | $972,704 | $48,635 | $1,021,339 |
The balance rises for the first decade because 5% growth on roughly $960,000 outruns a $40,000 withdrawal. It peaks around year 10 and then declines, because the withdrawal keeps compounding at 3% while the balance it draws from stops growing. Year 30 ends at $343,115.
Years 1 through 4 are identical. From year 5 the benefit covers part of the withdrawal, so the portfolio supplies only the difference. The benefit grows 3% a year from year 5, a stand-in for the cost-of-living adjustment.
| Year | Withdrawal | Social Security | From portfolio | End balance, no benefit | End balance, with benefit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | $45,020 | $30,000 | $15,020 | $1,030,566 | $1,062,066 |
| 10 | $52,191 | $34,778 | $17,413 | $1,030,440 | $1,260,459 |
| 20 | $70,140 | $46,739 | $23,401 | $874,206 | $1,784,821 |
| 30 | $94,263 | $62,813 | $31,449 | $343,115 | $2,546,668 |
Deterministic projection from this page’s calculator: withdrawal at the start of each year, 5% nominal return on the remainder, 3% inflation on the withdrawal and on the benefit from year 5. No taxes, fees, or required minimum distributions.
The 4% rule is older than most of the software that quotes it. William Bengen published “Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data” in the Journal of Financial Planning in October 1994. He modeled a portfolio of 50% common stocks and 50% intermediate-term Treasury notes, started a hypothetical retiree on January 1 of every year from 1926 forward, and measured how many years each portfolio lasted under a first-year withdrawal raised for inflation every year after.
His finding, in his words: a 4% first-year withdrawal “in no past case has caused a portfolio to be exhausted before 33 years, and in most cases it will lead to portfolio lives of 50 years or longer.” He called 3% (and up to about 3.5%) “absolutely safe” because it never failed inside 50 years, noted that 4.25% could run dry in as little as 28 years, and labeled a 5% start “risky” and 6% or more “gambling.” He also recommended holding between 50% and 75% in stocks throughout retirement.
The second pillar is the Trinity Study. Philip Cooley, Carl Hubbard and Daniel Walz of Trinity University published “Retirement Savings: Choosing a Withdrawal Rate That Is Sustainable” in the AAII Journal in February 1998, using returns from 1926 to 1995. Their contribution was the framing: instead of a single worst case, they reported a portfolio success rate, the share of historical starting years in which the money lasted the full period. In their 1999 follow-up with monthly withdrawals and data through 1997, a 50/50 stock and bond portfolio with inflation-adjusted withdrawals over 30 years succeeded 100% of the time at 3%, 95% at 4%, 70% at 5% and 51% at 6%. A 75/25 mix scored 100%, 100%, 86% and 63%.
Both studies have been updated. In A Richer Retirement (Wiley, August 2025), Bengen raised his 30-year figure to 4.7%, crediting a more diversified portfolio of seven asset classes at roughly 55% stocks, 40% bonds and 5% cash. Morningstar’s State of Retirement Income report dated December 3, 2025 goes the other direction: its base-case starting safe withdrawal rate is 3.9%, defined as the highest rate with a 90% probability of funds remaining after 30 years of fixed inflation-adjusted spending, excluding Social Security, with the best results from portfolios holding 30% to 50% in equities. That is up from 3.7% in its 2024 report and down from 4.0% in 2023. The same report finds a retiree willing to vary spending can start as high as 5.7%.
The practical reading for an advisor: the safe withdrawal rate is a range, roughly 3.9% to 4.7% today, and every figure in it assumes a 30-year horizon, a balanced portfolio and no spending flexibility. Change any of those and the number moves. The calculator above lets you see exactly how far.
The 4% rule is not “withdraw 4% every year.” Bengen was explicit: after the first year the withdrawal rate is no longer used. The dollar amount is last year’s withdrawal plus an inflation factor. At 3% inflation, a $40,000 first-year withdrawal becomes $52,191 in year 10, $70,140 in year 20 and $94,263 in year 30. The retiree is buying the same basket of goods the whole time.
This is why the balance in the first chart peaks and then falls. In the early years, 5% growth on roughly $960,000 exceeds a $40,000 draw. By year 20 the draw is $70,140 against a balance that has stopped growing, and the decline accelerates. A client who looks only at year one sees a comfortable 4% and a rising account. The year-30 withdrawal of $94,263 is the number that decides whether the plan holds, and it is the number a flat-dollar calculator never shows.
Untick the inflation box in the calculator and the same $40,000 lasts far longer, but the retiree’s purchasing power in year 30 is less than half of what it was in year one. Neither version is wrong; they answer different questions. The inflation-adjusted version is the one the research is built on.
This page uses one fixed return every year. Real portfolios do not. The order in which returns arrive matters as much as their average, because a withdrawal taken after a 20% drop sells more shares than the same withdrawal taken after a 20% gain. Two retirees with identical 30-year average returns can end with very different balances depending on which decade was bad. That is sequence-of-returns risk, and a steady-return model cannot show it. We will cover it on its own page, with the same worked example run through a bad first decade.
It is also not a Monte Carlo simulation. Monte Carlo runs the plan hundreds or thousands of times with randomized returns and reports a success rate, which is the framing the Trinity Study introduced and the one Morningstar’s 90% threshold uses. A single deterministic path gives a yes-or-no answer for one set of assumptions. It is the right tool for sizing a withdrawal and explaining the arithmetic to a client; it is the wrong tool for claiming a plan is safe.
Three more omissions, all deliberate. The model ignores taxes, so a $40,000 withdrawal from a traditional IRA is $40,000 of ordinary income the client does not get to spend in full. It ignores advisory and fund fees, which come out of the same return. And it ignores required minimum distributions, which can force a larger withdrawal than the plan calls for once the owner reaches 73. The next two sections take up Social Security and RMDs, and then the Medicare consequence of pre-tax withdrawals.
Every dollar withdrawn from a traditional IRA or 401(k) is ordinary income, and under 42 U.S.C. §1395r Medicare sets Part B and Part D premiums from modified adjusted gross income, defined as adjusted gross income plus tax-exempt interest, on the return from two years earlier. A 2026 withdrawal lands on 2028 premiums. In 2026 the first surcharge tier begins above $109,000 of MAGI for a single filer and $218,000 for a joint return, per the 2026 IRMAA brackets.
Cross either line by one dollar and the standard $202.90 Part B premium becomes $284.10, plus a $14.50 Part D surcharge, for each person on Medicare. That is $1,148.40 a year per person at the first tier, and the tiers climb to $689.90 a month for Part B alone. A married couple each on Medicare pays it twice. The surcharge is a cliff, not a phase-in, so a withdrawal strategy that lands $1 over a threshold costs the full tier.
This is where the account a withdrawal comes from matters as much as the amount. The same $40,000 taken from a Roth IRA adds nothing to MAGI; taken from a traditional IRA it adds $40,000. Our guide to the right kind and the wrong kind of retirement income sorts the sources, and how to reduce MAGI lists the levers. For a client with years between retirement and Medicare or RMDs, the Roth conversion calculator estimates what it costs to move pre-tax dollars out of the withdrawal path before the two-year lookback begins.
A standalone withdrawal calculator stops at the balance. The planning question is which accounts supply the withdrawal in which years, so that the income Medicare sees stays under the line while the spending the client needs stays on schedule.
The fastest way to see whether a client’s withdrawal plan holds is to run the household through a full plan. Book a live demo below and we’ll model one of your clients on the call: the withdrawal schedule, the Social Security filing age, the RMDs, and the IRMAA tiers each path touches.
Then keep going on the rules that shape what a client keeps after the withdrawal: the brackets, the thresholds, the Medicare costs, and the planning tools.
Withdrawals & Conversions
Income & Social Security
IRMAA & MAGI
Disclaimer: This article is educational content for financial professionals. It is not investment, tax, legal, insurance, or accounting advice, and it is not a recommendation of any security, strategy, or product. Any examples, figures, and calculations are hypothetical illustrations based on the stated assumptions and on tax and Medicare rules in effect at the time of writing, which are subject to change; they are not predictions or guarantees, and individual results will differ. RetirementAdvisorPro is not a registered investment adviser, broker-dealer, insurance agency, law firm, or accounting firm, and nothing here creates an advisory or professional-client relationship. Consult a qualified financial, tax, or legal professional regarding your specific circumstances. See our full disclosures.

Co-Founder of IRMAA Certified Planner, Founder of RetirementAdvisorPro
Mark Annese is an IRMAA Certified Planner specializing in helping financial advisors navigate Medicare income-related adjustments and optimize client retirement income strategies.
Common questions about our platform and services
Join financial advisors who are providing world-class retirement planning services with our AI-powered platform.
Social Security, RMDs and the Withdrawal Strategy
Social Security is the largest inflation-adjusted income most retirees will ever own, and the research figures above exclude it on purpose. In the worked example, a $30,000 benefit beginning in year 5 cuts the year-5 portfolio draw from $45,020 to $15,020, and the balance after 30 years rises from $343,115 to $2,546,668. The filing age sets the size of that benefit for life, which is why the claiming decision and the withdrawal rate belong in one plan; our guide to Social Security planning software for advisors covers what that plan should model.
Two cautions. First, benefits can be taxed. Under IRS Publication 915, once half of the benefit plus all other income, including tax-exempt interest, exceeds $25,000 for a single filer or $32,000 on a joint return, part of the benefit is taxable, and above $34,000 or $44,000 up to 85% of it is. Portfolio withdrawals from pre-tax accounts count toward those lines. We cover the mechanics on a separate page about whether Social Security is taxable. Second, the calculator treats the benefit as a simple offset; it does not model spousal or survivor benefits.
Required minimum distributions are the other constraint. Under 26 U.S.C. §401(a)(9), RMDs begin at age 73 for owners born 1951 through 1959 and at age 75 for owners born in 1960 or later, with the first one due by April 1 of the following year. At 73 the IRS requires about 3.77% of the prior year-end balance; by 85 it is 6.25%, and the share rises every year. For a client whose plan calls for 4% and whose savings sit mostly in a traditional IRA, the RMD overtakes the plan within a few years of 73. Run the forced amount through our RMD calculator, or read the full Uniform Lifetime Table to see the percentage at every age.